Today I noticed a (for me) unknown user 'robinloop' reviewing suggested edits:

enter image description here

What baffles me is that this is a new user, without reviews:

enter image description here

IIRC you need some more reputation than 1 before you are allowed to review, unless you approve an edit on your own post. But there are questions nor answers by that user.

I checked if 'robinloop' accepted a suggested edit on his/her own Question and if that question was then moved to some other SX site, but there are no (close) votes today that indicate that such a thing happened.

Another possibility would be that a post was edited and the changes accepted by 'robinloop', after which the post was flagged and removed. But I would the edit information in that case not get reset?

Do I miss something on how things work, or is there a loophole in the system of voting on suggested edits (including getting the Custodian badge)? Therefore not sure if a discussion item or a bug either.

1 Answer 1


The edit was on robinloop's own post like you guessed, but the post was subsequently deleted, so it doesn't show up in his profile

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .