22
For generic storage topics, there's already storage and block-device. For specific types of volume, there's lvm, device-mapper, etc. So I think we should just get rid of the uses of volume for storage topics, by retagging to existing tags. Eyeballing it, that's maybe 15 questions to retag.
Once we've done that, we should rename volume to something less ...
answered May 26 '15 at 7:07
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil'
654k5 gold badges54 silver badges112 bronze badges
20
No.
Our question volume is pretty low. Our most used distro tag (debian) got four questions in the last 24h. Our 2nd most used (ubuntu) got two. Things where this might make a little sense, like rhel got zero question in the last 24h.
It's hard to see that overwhelming our Debian or Ubuntu experts. And our RHEL experts must have fallen asleep at the ...
18
historical-unix is not a synonym of history at all. It's about Unix as a product, before there were multiple vendors.
Pretty much any question about historical-unix would deserve the tag history, because it hasn't been a current product for decades. But the converse is not true. historical-unix has a distinct meaning and must stay.
Overall the tag has ...
answered Aug 17 '18 at 21:22
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil'
654k5 gold badges54 silver badges112 bronze badges
18
After seeing the additional data, I'm leaning towards this idea:
base tag: exit-status (a new tag, utilizing the current return-status excerpt & wiki)
synonyms: exit-code, return-status, and return-code
I've created the exit-status tag and populated it with the return-status excerpt and wiki (slightly modified to say "exit status" instead of "return ...
18
I think it's a bit of a moot point. I skimmed through the questions tagged x, and the vast majority are Linux systems (so running X11), with the rare exceptions for X11 on macOS. There's no question here that's about X but using something other than X11, so the very existence of x can't be justified.
18
In my opinion, this tag should only be used for cases where a question is asking about how a Linux OS works. Not when the OP just happens to be using Linux, and not as a way of stating that the OP is using Linux. Tags should describe the question and help guide experts to questions they can answer. So the linux tag should only be used when the question is ...
16
gnu-screen was already set up as a synonym of screen. That means that anyone attempting to tag with gnu-screen would end up with screen.
I have now reversed the synonym so anyone tagging with screen will get gnu-screen instead. I've also retagged the questions you linked to.
15
I don't see much of a use case for it. You can just remove it from the post; unused tags are deleted daily, so it'll get removed automatically
15
A windows subsystem for Linux makes me think of X11, some subsystem to manage windows on Linux.
After googling it, it looks more like it's some Microsoft product to run GNU/Unix/Ubuntu applications on Microsoft Windows operating systems, rather than something like wine to run MS Windows applications on Linux-based systems as the name would suggest.
IMO, ...
15
I agree with your logic and IMO it should be removed.
15
We are barking up the wrong tree. We can put whatever we want in the excerpt and the wiki, and it won't make any difference to any but a vanishingly small proportion of askers. What we should do is ask SE for a tag warning, a la this warning implemented in Ask Ubuntu. I think the feature is still buggy (IIRC if you post the question right after adding the ...
14
I don't recall seeing a question about LVM1 on this site. It was already obsolete by the time this site started. So for all intents and purposes lvm and lvm2 are currently equivalent.
I favor merging them, and making lvm the main tag. (Only moderators can do this.)
If an incompatible LVM3 comes along, we can start using lvm3 for it. Then make lvm2 the main ...
answered Sep 23 '13 at 21:59
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil'
654k5 gold badges54 silver badges112 bronze badges
14
Blacklisted:
14
I moved all existing alpine posts into either alpine-linux or alpine-mail. I also put in a request to blacklist the tag since it still exists on Stack Overflow (where it's the distro), Super User (where it's the mail client), and Server Fault (where it's not specified), and all of them migrate to us regularly.
Edit: I'm told that now that the tag is fully ...
13
I support this proposal. The two versions of grub share a name but are configured and managed in ways that make answers or suggestions meant for one innapropriate for the other. Additionally, grub2 has enough new features that it will function in installations that either grub won't (EFI) or is difficult (/ on lvm,raid).
Getting rid of grub in favor of grub-...
13
Tags help display questions to the right people. They don't mainly function to describe a question.
Tags are mainly additive, not subtractive. People follow tags to hear about new questions in those tags. Its possible to ignore tags as well, but that's only kali-linux ;-). So for the most part, adding a tag adds audience; removing a tag removes audience.
...
13
The questions that have the tag are correctly tagged, they are about careers. So don't edit the questions to remove the tag.
Most of the questions with this tag are already closed. If we decide we don't want career-related questions, then we should finish the job: close and delete the undesirable questions. Once there are no non-deleted questions with the ...
answered Apr 4 '17 at 11:58
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil'
654k5 gold badges54 silver badges112 bronze badges
12
I think you are correct @Gilles. Your logic is correct and easy to follow. If I had enough reputation points to make those two tags synonyms, I would.
12
EFI and UEFI refer to different versions of the same thing.
In the mid 1990s, Intel began working on an improvement over the PC BIOS in order to work well with the more powerful machines they were building. The result was an Extensible Firmware Interface (EFI), and Intel still hosts the version of the specification they published in 2002. In 2005, Intel ...
12
I can't see a difference in the type of questions that have one tag or the other. People seem to indifferently use one or the other.
Since the libvirt library and the libvirtd daemon interact with each other, and there is no alternative implementation of either as far as I know, very few issues involve only the library or only the daemon. Furthermore, “...
answered Jan 18 '18 at 19:45
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil'
654k5 gold badges54 silver badges112 bronze badges
11
router seems to get questions actually about routers—the <$100 Linksys, etc. boxes. Things like loading custom firmware on them, and getting WiFi connections to work.
routing seems to actually get questions about IP routing. route seems to be the same thing. Suggest merging both to routing.
I suggest keeping router for questions about the Linux aspects ...
11
I think the use of format to mean creating a file system is going to be hard to eradicate. As you point out, most people won't know what mkfs is while format is a household term. This is always going to be a hard tag to deal with since it can be used to mean so many different things.
The best solution I can see would be to blacklist the tag. Then, when ...
11
Q&As about Kali Linux, a Linux distribution based on Debian that is specifically intended for use by security specialists, not as a general-purpose operating system. Please read the information for Kali Linux questions and answers that is linked-to in the corner of this box.
Kali Linux is a security-related Linux-based operating system, derived from ...
10
My first impression is that kernel-drivers should be merged into drivers, and module was created by someone who typed kernel module as separate words and grew from there. This is to be confirmed by browsing through the questions list which I haven't done yet.
Only 16 questions are tagged module but not kernel-modules or kernel. 8 of these are about Linux ...
answered Jun 13 '14 at 12:07
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil'
654k5 gold badges54 silver badges112 bronze badges
10
I think it is ok to have both the generic [shell] tag and a specific shell tag on a question. My interpretation of this answer supports this. That question is about tagging programming questions on SO and Shog9 recommends two tags -- language and API. This is essentially a broad topic and a drilled down specific topic.
For the specific case you mention:...
10
The tag length limit has been raised, so windows-subsystem-for-linux is now a valid tag name.
answered Aug 9 '17 at 0:21
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil'
654k5 gold badges54 silver badges112 bronze badges
10
I've cleaned up the jessie and stretch tags. As I understand it, if the tags don't get any new content they should be automatically deleted.
10
You’re right that they’re they same. According to the Polkit Wikipedia article,
Since version 0.105, released in 2015 the name of the project was changed
from PolicyKit to polkit.
Also, the tag wiki excerpt for policykit is a copy of the first line of the above Wikipedia article,
Polkit (formerly PolicyKit) is a component for controlling system-wide
...
10
I’ve created the relevant synonym, all it needs now is votes. Any user with an answer score of 5 or more on system-calls can vote! I had misread the requirements previously, it turns out there are quite a few users meeting the requirements. (The answer score is the number of upvotes on answers in the tag, minus the number of downvotes on answers in the tag.)
9
There are already a bunch of questions on this topic on the main meta:
Should I retag a question with a tag that is based on the answer and not the question?
Retagging questions in terms of possible answer technologies
Retagging questions with the answer?
Should question include tags that are mentioned only in answers?
In summary, the thinking seems to be ...
Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible
