7

There are 12 questions tagged as :

A loop device allows any file to be mounted as a filesystem image. Not to be confused with a loopback interface in networking.

From those

  • 4 are about loop devices,
  • 8 are about control flows.

I bring this in attention of moderators as I find the current situation confusing.

As my personal point of view, the tag should remain as is for the 4 loop device questions and the 8 control flow questions should loose their tags.

6

I don't remember for sure, but I suspect the choice to have mean loop devices rather than control flow is due to programming being mostly off-topic on this site. Loop constructs in shells do come up from time to time, and it's natural to use the loop tag in this sense.

Given the wide mismatch between documented meaning and actual use, I've retagged the loop device questions to and copied over the tag wiki.

It remains to be seen what to do with : should it be a synonym of ? Or should it be blacklisted? Note that in addition to being a natural choice for the (rare) questions about loop constructs, it is likely to come up in migrations from Stack Overflow.

  • If it's a synonym people will probably continue to use it wrong without noticing. Generally questions from SO need editing anyway, so I'm not worried about needing to add it to questions from them – Michael Mrozek Sep 17 '11 at 21:27
  • Wrong? But if it's a synonym of control-flow, it's more likely to be used right. – Gilles 'SO- stop being evil' Sep 17 '11 at 21:29
  • I mean people tagging [loop] when they mean [loop-devices], which they can't do if there's no [loop] to begin with. I guess hopefully they'll notice the latter in the tag editor – Michael Mrozek Sep 17 '11 at 21:37
  • If loop will pertain to for and while related questions, then would be logic (and politically correct) to also have conditional tag for if and case related questions. – manatwork Sep 18 '11 at 11:33
5

As you pointed out, 's tag wiki is about loopback devices, so I left those 4 and retagged the other 8 to . It might be a good idea to change the remaining questions to something like to avoid future confusion, but I left it for the moment (anyone with 500 rep is welcome to retag them)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .