-5

I can see that more and more questions about this topic are posted on Super User or Unix & Linux. It usually goes like this:

Someone bought a used Chromebook online (eBay, Amazon Marketplace, Craigslist, …) but the device is enrolled to the Chromebook for Enterprise or Education environment and cannot be used like a privately owned Chromebook.

For reference here is what the support page says:

Reset a work or school Chromebook

If you're using your Chromebook at work or school, you can't reset it. Ask your administrator to wipe the data on your Chromebook and re-enroll the device on your work or school network.

From my point of view any modification to these devices is very likely to be illegal (as in computer fraud, sabotage or possession of stolen goods), so such questions should better be closed and a recommendation be given to the OP to return the device.

I'm aware that there is a slight chance of sloppy managed enrolled devices being sold online, enrollment though should be removed when the device can be kept after leaving the organization in question—thus weaken the argument of spying on users. No customer should have to deal with this nor should sites like Stack Exchange and other communities.

In case of an employee or student of the respective organization being unhappy with the device being enrolled s/he should contact the respective administrator or contact person of the organization instead of asking for hacking advice. A clear distinction between company/organization property and privately owned may also help here understanding why things are as they are.

Cross-posted to Superuser: https://meta.superuser.com/q/12697/252532

  • 6
    Why illegal? And if some poor dupe has bought something on ebay that was stolen, why penalize them? We're not here to enforce any laws after all. – terdon Oct 12 '17 at 13:55
  • 1
    Recommending to return the device and request a refund or fix of the problem isn't a penalty from my point of view but constructive feedback so that such devices don't get into average consumers hands. If you have an easier or better solution and have no doubts that this is similar to the hackintosh context, then I'm all ears. What ever solves the problem is good enough for me. – LiveWireBT Oct 12 '17 at 15:42
  • 4
    I'm trying to understand if there is a problem and what that problem would be. I might simply be misunderstanding you here, I don't have any experience with this sort of "enterprise" hardware. However, I do know that we don't enforce laws on SE since i) we're not lawyers and ii) this is an international site and the jurisdiction would be complicated. Where would this be illegal? Where is the OP? Also, what would the answer be? If there is one, we may as well give it. If it's impossible, we can say that. Are you suggesting we consider these questions off topic? On what grounds? – terdon Oct 12 '17 at 15:49
  • 1
    I'm also not a lawyer. All I know is that someone from the hacking community probably knows how but isn't willing to share this info for some reason. Unless someone else knows how (MrChromebox offers Unbricking) and is willing to share then we don't have an answer, thus returning such a device looks like the best advice to me. If it was all fine and dandy it would have probably been posted on chromium.org/chromium-os by now where you can find all of the other info to dig around in the OS and hardware internals. Sorry that's really all I know. – LiveWireBT Oct 12 '17 at 16:11
  • 3
    Fair enough. And thanks for bringing this up. I'm not trying to argue here, only to understand. – terdon Oct 12 '17 at 16:12
5

Computer fraud, sabotage? What on earth makes you think that? Buying a second-hand computer is legal! Organizations sell their old hardware, you know. I don't doubt that there are stolen goods on eBay sometimes, but most goods on eBay are perfectly legitimate.

In any case, we give people the benefit of doubt. And we do not censor questions based on hypothesized security policies.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .